ERC Hard Truths: Your ERC Claim May Have Already Been Denied

Thunderbolt TaxNow Icon
TaxNow
17 Mar 2026
ERC Hard Truths: Your ERC Claim May Have Already Been Denied

What if the IRS already resolved your ERC claim, and just never told you? Over the weekend, TaxNow’s transcript monitoring data surfaced something important.

It appears the IRS has now substantially processed most ERC claims that were not in a “special situations” category.

“Special situations” is our term, not the IRS’s, but it’s the easiest way to describe the buckets where remaining claims appear to live.

Those situations include claims that are:

Bullet Point
Under examination
Bullet Point
Formally denied
Bullet Point
Processed but administratively held
Bullet Point
Stalled due to account issues or processing conflicts
Bullet Point
Quietly denied

In other words, the ERC “backlog” may largely be gone, but that does not mean every taxpayer received a refund.

The Numbers Don't Quite Reconcile

Recently, the IRS suggested that somewhere between 0 and 29,000 ERC claims remained pending.

Meanwhile, practitioner groups like the HIRE Coalition have estimated that hundreds of thousands of claims were still outstanding.

Both statements cannot simultaneously be true.  “The February 2026 GAO report and last week’s testimony from the IRS CEO suggest all ERC claims are closed or in compliance. However, the numbers reported by TAS and a recent survey by the HIRE Coalition suggest another story,” said Tim Parrish, President of HIRE Coalition.

One possible explanation is that a large number of claims were resolved internally without taxpayers fully realizing it yet.

That resolution may include disallowance decisions that are not immediately obvious unless you review the IRS account transcript carefully.

What Your Transcript May Be Telling You

ERC claims generally fall into one of several transcript patterns.

Understanding these patterns can reveal what actually happened to your claim.

1. Claims Under Examination

Claims under audit typically show:

Transaction Codes

Bullet Point
420 – examination indicator
Bullet Point
424 – examination request

These often appear together.

For some taxpayers, this has already triggered:

Bullet Point
Letter 6612
Bullet Point
IDR (Information Document Request)

Others may see the exam codes but have not received correspondence yet.

That can happen.

Mail gets lost more often than practitioners would like to admit.

If you fall into this category, it may be worth:

Bullet Point
Contacting the IRS
Bullet Point
Opening a case with the Taxpayer Advocate Service (TAS)
Bullet Point
Requesting your file through a FOIA request

2. Formal ERC Denials

Formal denials are the most straightforward category.

These usually involve:

Transcript signals

Bullet Point
TC 290 adjustment
Bullet Point
Followed by Letter 105C or 106C

These are Notices of Claim Disallowance.

Once issued, they start the two-year statute to challenge the denial in federal court.

If you receive one of these letters and disagree with the IRS determination, it is important to follow the instructions for administrative appeal or litigation.

Victoria Beck, General Counsel for Sagemont Advisors, warns, “As more ERC claims move into examination or are formally disallowed, the central issue for many businesses is shifting from waiting for their refund to how best to respond to the IRS’s determination. That process typically requires a disciplined approach to developing the administrative record, evaluating appellate options within the IRS, and, where appropriate, preserving the ability to challenge the denial in court.”

3. Approved but "Held" Refunds

Another common scenario is a claim that appears approved but not paid.

These transcripts typically show:

Bullet Point
TC 291 / TC 766 credit postings
Bullet Point
But no TC 846 refund issued

In plain English:

The credit was allowed, but the refund has not been released.

Refunds can be held for several administrative reasons:

Bullet Point
Bankruptcy review
Bullet Point
Penalty offset analysis
Bullet Point
Statute verification
Bullet Point
Compliance checks
Bullet Point
Other account freezes

If the refund has been sitting in this state for 45 days or longer, taxpayers often have success by:

Bullet Point
Calling the IRS and requesting a referral
Bullet Point
Contacting the Taxpayer Advocate Service

The good news here is that the credit was initially approved.

The remaining challenge is simply clearing the administrative hold.

4. Lost or Stolen ERC Checks

If your transcript shows “TC 846 – Refund issued”, but the check never arrived, the likely issue is simply a lost or stolen check.

In those cases, the IRS recommends filing Form 3911 to initiate a refund trace.

This form can be faxed.

5. The "Quietly Denied" Category

The final category is the most confusing.

These are claims where transcripts strongly suggest the claim was resolved against the taxpayer, even though the taxpayer may not yet realize it.

Common indicators include:

A. TC 290 adjustments

Even if a formal disallowance letter has not yet been received, a 290 adjustment associated with the ERC period can signal that the claim has already been resolved.

B. Prior ERC processing on an earlier filing

If the transcript shows:

Bullet Point
291 / 766 credit postings before the final 971 / 976

The presence of these codes can indicate that ERC was already processed on an original return or earlier amended return, and a later amendment did not generate an additional credit.

C. Multiple amended returns

Repeated 971 / 976 entries may indicate multiple amended returns were filed.

In those situations, the IRS may process the earliest valid claim and ignore subsequent filings without formally denying the later-filed amended return.  This is particularly common when the amended returns were filed within close proximity of one another.

D. Missing original return indicators

If the transcript does not show:

TC 150 – original return filed

The IRS may not have had a valid base return to process the ERC claim against.

E. Statute issues

Certain claims may also run into statute limitations.

Notably, legislation enacted in 2025 prevents the IRS from allowing ERC refunds for Q3 or Q4 2021 claims filed after January 31, 2024, even if the claim would otherwise have been timely.

The Bottom Line

The ERC story is entering a new phase. For the last two years, the conversation centered on the backlog. Now the real challenge is understanding what actually happened to millions of claims.

For most taxpayers, the answer will fall into one of five categories:

Bullet Point
Audit
Bullet Point
Denial
Bullet Point
Administrative hold
Bullet Point
Lost refund
Bullet Point
Successful payment

But if your refund never arrived, the most important thing you can do is review your IRS transcripts. They often tell the story long before the IRS does.

If you believe your ERC claim may fall into one of these categories, I’m happy to take a look.

You can email me directly at Kenneth@taxnow.com with your transcripts or access through your TaxNow account, and I will provide a complimentary second opinion.
Join TaxNow Newsletter
TaxNow Thunderbolt
Text Link

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Suspendisse varius enim in eros elementum tristique. Duis cursus, mi quis viverra ornare, eros dolor interdum nulla, ut commodo diam libero vitae erat. Aenean faucibus nibh et justo cursus id rutrum lorem imperdiet. Nunc ut sem vitae risus tristique posuere.